Wednesday, December 20, 2006

Slow Growing Breastcancer

Padulle, history (second part)

What follows is a guide, written in summer 2003, an episode of the troubled history of the detailed plan of Padulle that, it certainly was not decisive in marking the progress of the story, however, is an example of how the whole issue has been managed Padulle.

I refer consideration of the detailed plan by the district council, which is examining the case (and as we shall see) in spring-summer 2003 when the board of district No. 4 was called upon to express an opinion on the plan in view of its adoption.


------------------

Wednesday, June 4 last year, at the offices of District No. 4, was held the meeting dedicated to the presentation of the detailed plan consortium for Padulle (Zone C5, according to the PRG) by the engineer. Ferri, drafter of the plan on behalf of members in the consortium, Councillor Melucci and urban planning.
The plan, at least in its essentials, was already known to all the interesting and perhaps why, after the presentation of only a few questions to the speakers focused on the actual plan.
Those few was the amount of the cost of urbanization, estimated roughly, and subject, Eng. Ferri around 3 million euro for the whole area and the possible granting of an exemption from the town from some taxes on the building permit. This exemption (or at least a steep discount) seems reasonable since the cost of primary infrastructure, which normally would justify the charge, will be directly charged to the owners of the consortium members and the City.
We are not members of the consortium have used the occasion to reaffirm once again the reasons for our disagreement with some aspects of the transaction are objectively burdensome and discriminatory for the owners of lots rather large (relative to others) and free manufactured by raising, as was done in all possible locations, the problem of the absurd disparity between large and small landowners created by the rule of the PRG that assigns the same building capacity (less than 600 square meters) to the owner of a plot of 600 sqm on which there is already a building of 200 square meters and the owner of a vacant lot of 15,000 square meters, in addition to this plus the premium for an undifferentiated land subject to easements (power line, highway) and one without, also those who already have an existing structure does not undergo any reduction and may even change its intended use with a lot maybe just enough to contain the underlying (the right conferred by the structure built up in these owners, who certainly did not expect, about 600 square meters of building area, it is certainly illegal and this is the consequence of an aberrant standard badly written and performed worse than the same from Mr. Prato has called "indefinite": it should be noted, incidentally, that this blessed "urban equalization" was a key point in the election campaign of Mayor to which the Government undertook to give a precise meaning and condition laid down by the Communist PRC to support the Mayor.
In doing so we had to collide with an atmosphere vaguely threatening (in some regrettable isolated cases, and fortunately, not so very vaguely) is created by some of the members of the consortium, which, aided by the provision in question, are understandably determined to defend both Melucci by the same assessor who reiterated, as was done in other forums that "this is the only possible solution for Padulle" and that "there is no alternative to the standard."
Claims Councillor Melucci we seem serious because it is vaguely to blackmail those who disagrees with the approach of this operation (sound a bit 'like' or do this or do nothing ") because it is objectively baseless.
not one but many different solutions and fairer in our view are not only possible, but indeed, and in many ways, preferable, even the signs of the master plan proposed that the system even if it seems to have enough room for flexibility to support even a revision in the sense of balancing rule proposed by the PRG, it seems too widespread building solutions with excessive "waste of land, also the location of residential buildings in the vicinity of a large factory or a highway does not seem the best.
We hold to fight for the recognition of something so obvious and gross, while the local administration, especially but not only, in the person councilor Melucci continues in its stores to "mirror climbing" to sustain the unsustainable. On some occasions the assessor
Melucci argued against the law and against all reason, that assign development rights in proportion to the extent of the property do not mean that the smoothing and equalization was done with the real under the PRG.
During assembly district has corrected the shooting, claiming (against literally as provided by PRG and also quoted verbatim in the meeting by the chairman of the board of the district) and that of Padulle is not an area for urban expansion, but an area of \u200b\u200bregeneration and that this feature is irrelevant and misleading discussion of any equalization.
We are in a Kafkaesque situation in which citizens are forced to fight for the simple recognition of obvious principles of fairness and the municipal authority defends choices patently absurd and arbitrary and specious arguments divorced from social and legal context in which we live and from reality. Then we arrive
incredible when Melucci argues that this experience, that on the specific point we dispute, has drawn criticism, sidelined through various stratagems, throughout the process of approval of the PRG, which resulted in an appeal to the TAR, is still pending, by the parties directly concerned, so shrill as to create serious fractures between involved, is considered an example and a model to be exported as soon as possible in other areas of the town and maybe even beyond.

evaluating the overall story line throughout the estate, where each formal openness to dialogue has always been accompanied by the complete unwillingness to address the specific facts of the case, all the actions and statements are configured councilor Melucci as a mere show of force, a blunt assertion of its power, against all common sense and against all reason.

In this context it is not surprising that much about the decision of the district to skip the review stage in the building commission of the proposed detailed plan, consideration of practice for much less relevant to this action is particularly useful in this case because the actions of some advisers have made clear how the ideas they have on the subject are far from clear.
The choice is then singular at least if one takes into account the fact that the board of the district, at the time, expressed himself negatively about the rule of the PRG on which the plan is founded (under which, incidentally, has been criticized by those who have found themselves to examine it, but who is "miraculously" survived almost unchanged up to now).
's still more singular that the decision to skip the step in the committee is officially justified by the fact that the chairman of the committee is just the engineer. Ferri, drafter of the plan.

Finally, I bit that goes beyond a 'from the particular story and places it in a broader context.
The decision not to consider the plan in the building commission, the accuracy demonstrated by the actions of certain directors and the final gaffe of the President of the Board of neighborhood, caught in a Freudian slip, said that "the Board will meet Monday, June 16 for" approve "the proposed plan" (as opposed to "discuss and vote ") then say a lot about how the advice of district, which could be an important site for the training of civilian and democratic citizens are from this point of view, a missed opportunity, because too often will simply endorse without a real discussion that decisions are taken elsewhere.

On 16 June, then promptly turn the " session approval of the plan during which it appeared almost no knowledge of the plan by the district council, whose work never entered the debate on the plan, but tending mostly to please the large audience (the consortium was organized as a group of hooligans in a stadium) have maintained a level worthy of a chat that does not bar a public meeting. A wonderfully unseemly.

More generally the whole episode shows how a system of Padulle obviously ill, in which democratic control is more formal than substantive, and let it grow to bear the legal monsters, if powerful enough to have sponsors, have been going against all common sense and against all reason, also because of a Justice slow and cumbersome administration that fails to be an effective deterrent to abuse.

0 comments:

Post a Comment